Unmarried and Buying a Home? You Might Need a Deed of Trust
More unmarried couples than ever are choosing to buy homes together, viewing homeownership as both a financial investment and a symbol of commitment. However, without the legal protections that marriage provides, it’s crucial to establish clear ownership terms. A Deed of Trust for unmarried couples can help safeguard each partner’s financial contributions, ensuring that assets and liabilities are handled fairly—both during the relationship and in the event of separation, death, or other unforeseen circumstances.
Overview of Joint Property Ownership
When two individuals purchase property together, typically, they hold the title as either “joint tenants” or “tenants in common.” Understanding the difference between joint tenancy and tenants in common is essential to better appreciating the importance of a deed of trust.
The most significant difference is the presence or absence of the “right of survivorship.” In joint tenancy, the surviving partner has a right to the property. In tenants in common, the deceased’s share of the property becomes part of their estate.
- Joint Tenants refers to a situation in which both parties hold equal rights to the property. If one owner passes away, that owner’s share automatically transfers to the other owner. This scenario typically applies to married individuals.
- In a Tenants-in-Common regime, each party separately owns a specific percentage of the property. If one owner passes away, their share transmits to their heirs or someone other than the remaining owner.
If married, the property relationship between partners is mainly governed by a marriage settlement. However, the situation is different if the couples are unmarried.
Why a Deed of Trust is Essential for Unmarried Homebuyers
Before purchasing a property together, it is important to have an open discussion on each other’s financial and legal responsibilities. This includes understanding mortgage responsibilities, property tax obligations, and the potential consequences of future conflicts or separations.
One document that can help is a Deed of Trust for unmarried couples. A Deed of Trust specifies the ownership terms and the rights of each party. Here are the ways it can help:
- Clarifies Ownership: A Deed of Trust specifies the ownership of the property and establishes the process if one or both partners want to sell their share. It is also applicable if one partner becomes incapacitated.
- Protects Interests: If the relationship ends or conflicts arise, the Deed of Trust acts as a reference that can assist in resolving disputes amicably, detailing how the property will be divided or managed.
- Specifies Financial Responsibilities: A Deed of Trust can specify each partner’s monetary contributions to the mortgage, property maintenance, and other expenses, minimizing future misunderstandings.
However, a common challenge occurs when one partner contributes a larger upfront deposit while both share responsibility for the mortgage.
The Challenge of Unequal Deposit
When there’s an unequal deposit, a Deed of Trust for unmarried couples can define how equity, future profits, and mortgage responsibilities are divided, ensuring fairness for both partners.
What’s the best way to fairly divide equity and future profits?
- Fairly dividing equity and future profits among the involved parties is a challenge. This requires not only an assessment of initial contributions but also an understanding of how future growth and revenue will be shared.
How can you balance mortgage contributions with initial investments?
- Another challenge is the balancing of initial investments with mortgage contributions. Parties are faced with the complexities of each person’s financial input.
How can you avoid disputes over financial fairness in the future?
- Lastly, property contributions must be safeguarded against future disputes. Clear communication, thorough documentation, and mutual agreement on how financial matters will be managed can help prevent misunderstandings and conflicts later down the line.
In the presence of unequal contribution, how can the partner who made the larger deposit be protected? What happens when the partners break up? What occurs if the value of the property appreciates?
A Deed of Trust is the Solution
This is why a Deed of Trust is essential. First, it clarifies ownership and prevents future disputes. Next, it outlines guidelines for adjusting ownership shares later on. Lastly, it establishes exit strategies before buying.
The deed must clearly outline the (a) contributions of each partner; (b) their ownership equity; (c) the distribution system of profit or during liquidation; (d) how improvements will be handled; and (e) dispute resolution.
(A) Contributions:
The deed must meticulously detail each partner’s financial and non-financial contributions. This includes:
- Down payments
- Mortgage payments
- Property improvements
- Labor contributions
- Any other form of contribution investment
For example: “Partner X contributed 70% of the initial down payment, while partner Y contributed 30%. Partner X has also consistently contributed 75% of the monthly mortgage payments.”
(B) Ownership:
Although a provision exists regarding each partner’s contribution, it is still advisable to specify the ownership each partner holds. Distribution may happen after the property is sold or when it generates income (e.g., rental income). To avoid confusion or unfairness, this percentage of ownership should also be consistent with the distribution of proceeds.
This may be referred to as absolute proportionality. In this framework, the percentage of each partner’s contribution to the capital is the same as their share in the investment profits.
For example: “Due to unequal financial contributions, Partner X holds a 70% ownership stake in the property, while Partner Y holds a 30% ownership stake. In the event of a property sale or income generation, the same percentage will apply to each partner, respectively.”
However, a couple may take a different approach, opting for “equal distribution” after the return of their capital.
(C) Distribution of Proceeds:
Fixed Share Approach: In this model, the larger contributor receives their deposit back first, after which profits are equally divided. This arrangement safeguards the initial contributions, making it fair for those investing more upfront.
Proposed Floating Share Model: Each contributor’s deposit determines their share in the overall property appreciation. If the property appreciates, their deposit rises as well. After both parties take their adjusted deposit, the profits are split. This arrangement is seen as more beneficial and is favored by the lower contributor regarding long-term value appreciation.
The question of how to fairly balance equity and mortgage payments hinges on each party’s perception of what is equitable for both partners’ contributions.
Remember that contributions include both industrial and non-financial aspects. Financial contributions include deposits and future contributions, including maintenance, contingencies, and overpayments.
If only the share in profits is stipulated, the share in losses will be in the same proportion.
(D) Handling of Improvements:
Owning a property requires improvements, which are inevitable. The deed can specify how those contributions will be valued and incorporated into the profit distribution.
For example: “If one partner pays for a major renovation, the reimbursement will be taken from the net profit before the remaining profit is distributed.”
This straightforward clause provides clarity and prevents future conflicts.
(E) Arbitration Clause:
The deed should include a clause resolving disputes related to the property. This clause is legally enforceable and requires good faith compliance.
This may involve agreeing to accept the decision of an independent arbiter, who must be competent and impartial regarding the property and the partners.
(F) Clarity:
It is essential that the deed of trust uses clear and unambiguous language to prevent future misunderstandings.
(G) Important Considerations:
- Each party should maintain an accurate record of contributions.
- It’s important for both partners to obtain independent legal advice before signing a Deed of Trust. This ensures that everyone understands their rights and obligations.
- It’s essential to ensure that the Deed of Trust complies with the laws of the relevant state.
Final Thoughts
In summary, unmarried couples should carefully assess how unequal contributions may affect their ownership rights when purchasing a home together. Open financial discussions are essential, but securing a Deed of Trust for unmarried couples provides an added layer of clarity and legal protection. With a Deed of Trust, both partners can safeguard their investments and avoid potential disputes in the future.
For a quick and hassle-free way to create your Deed of Trust, use FormPros to generate and download a legally compliant document online today.
FormPros Has You Covered
Simplify your paperwork with FormPros! From creating paystubs, W-2s, and 1099-NEC forms to generating LLC Operating Agreements and even voided checks, our easy-to-use platform has you covered. Save time, reduce errors, and handle your business documents with confidence. Start now and see how FormPros makes professional form generation fast, affordable, and hassle-free!
